Best Exfoliating Soap Bars (Top 10 Choices + 15 Alternatives)

Summary

Shopping for the best exfoliating soap bars can be a little difficult if you are not sure as to what you have to look for. Exfoliating soap bars are great at keeping the skin looking healthy and refreshed, but there’s a lot of them on the market.

We made this guide to help you shop for the right exfoliating soap. We hope you find these reviews useful!

Introduction

If you have been having problems with dry patches, flaking, and uneven skin tone and texture, chances are, you need to exfoliate more. Regardless of whether you have these problems or not, you need to be exfoliating regularly as part of your routine.

Luckily, there are many products that can help you achieve this goal. The hard part is selecting the best exfoliating soap bars. Go over our reviews below and see which one works for you.

​Top 3 Choices

1. Dove Men+Care Body and Face Bar Deep Clean

We are putting this men’s exfoliating soap bar from Dove in the top spot because of the technology in it. By nature, men’s skin are thicker than ours, and they tend to sweat more and produce more oil. We love the micrograins mixed with the cream in this soap because they provide that gentle exfoliation needed by our loved ones without making them smell like flowers.

2. Aspen Kay Naturals Oatmeal Soap Bar

You may enjoy the balanced exfoliation and moisture that this soap bar offers. The oatmeal bits provide gentle exfoliation, and the goat milk and honey take care of moisture. This is great especially if you’re looking for a 2-in-1 solution or if you’re not quite ready for a very thorough exfoliation. Aspen Kay Naturals also offers a lot of other natural solutions for the skin that you may like.

3. Dove Beauty Bar Gentle Exfoliating

Finally, we’re putting Dove’s gentle exfoliating beauty bar in the third spot for two reasons. First, it works well while remaining very mild for sensitive skin. Second, it is a tested and proven product that consistently gets high ratings and glowing reviews online, which only prove that although it’s not a perfect product and by no means does it please everyone, it definitely makes a lot of women happy.

Top 3 Choices - Comparison Table

Dove Men+Care Body and Face Bar Deep Clean

Aspen Kay Naturals Oatmeal Soap Bar

Dove Beauty Bar Gentle Exfoliating

Ingredients

Moisturizing cream, micrograins

Oatmeal, goat milk, honey

Moisturizing cream

Weight

4 oz

4 oz

4 oz

Ratings

Who Is It For?

We recommend that you use one of the best exfoliating soap bars around if you constantly have problems with dead skin cells. Common symptoms of this problem include flaking, dry patches, and a rough overall texture.

You don’t even have to wait until you encounter these problems. You have to exfoliate as part of your skin care routine. So, whether you’re looking into exfoliation because your skin is showing signs of trouble or because  you just want well-maintained skin, these exfoliating soap bars are for you.

Buyer's Guide

Benefits of Antibacterial Soap

You may often read or hear about exfoliation in beauty magazines and TV shows, and they all talk about how it is supposed to get rid of dead skin cells. But what good does it do exactly? Here are the most important benefits of exfoliation.

1. Glowing skin

Dead skin is uneven, ugly, rough, and even flaky at times. Therefore, it is difficult to apply makeup when the skin is covered in dead skin cells. When you gently and regularly exfoliate, you remove those dead skin and reveal the healthy, fresh, and smooth new skin underneath.

2. Minimized pores

Pores are small holes in the skin which are connected to your oil glands through follicles. These pores expand (read: distractingly huge pores that can be seen from a mile away) when they fill up with sebum, dirt, and of course, dead skin cells. Exfoliation removes these blockages, thereby keeping your pores from getting larger.

3. Acne prevention

Acne mainly results from sebum build-up in the pores. As mentioned, exfoliation takes care of cleansing your pores, thereby reducing the probability of you getting acne. Take note that clogged pores are not the only factors that cause acne, which means that you may have to do more than just exfoliate if you are indeed dealing with acne.

4. Indirect anti-aging effects

Putting makeup on a poorly exfoliated face with lots of dead skin cells tends to magnify wrinkles and fine lines because the makeup “sits” on top of these cells. By exfoliating, your skin becomes even, and you can now successfully conceal those fine lines behind your expensive makeup.

5. Skin care product absorption

If your pores are blocked, no skin care product, regardless of ingredients or price or brand, can penetrate your skin. You have to regularly clear your pores to make sure that your skin care regime is working.

6. Great tan

Do not forget to do a full-body exfoliation before sunbathing. Otherwise, it is your dead skin cells that will be tanned. That means it will be shed by the body quickly. When you sunbathe with a freshly exfoliated skin, it is your new skin cells that will be tanned, and it will last longer.

​Review of Top 10 Products

1. Dove Beauty Bar Gentle Exfoliating

Description

Dove has always been our go-to brand whenever we want an effective but mild product. Dove products are so gentle that it always gets recommended by dermatologists for patients with sensitive skin. You may love this product because although it is meant to exfoliate, the company did not skip their signature “¼ moisturizing cream” formula. This product has been around for a while, and a lot of women are more than happy to continue using it.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 4 oz
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: moisturizing cream, exfoliating beads

Features & Benefits

Brand

As is the case with other skin care products, brand plays an important part in choosing the right exfoliating soap bar. Dove has been around for a long time and remains a reputable company in the world of beauty products. They already have the trust of millions.

Exfoliating Beads

Carefully formulated in Dove’s high-end laboratories, the small beads in this soap provide just the right amount of exfoliation for your skin. They are gentle, so you may want to give this product a try if you are very sensitive or are afraid of the harsh exfoliation that scrubs and other soaps tend to produce.

Moisturizing Cream

The moisturizer in the Dove products we’ve gotten used to is also here, which is great because that means you do not have to put on as much of your moisturizer after your shower. It also means you can just buy one soap instead of having to go for a set.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Very gentle
  • check-circle
    Smells good
  • check-circle
    Skin remains smooth after
  • times-circle
    Sensitive users may react to the scent

2. Pre de Provence Shea Butter Enriched Artisanal French Soap Bar - Herbs of Provence

Description

Can we just say first how much we love the look of this soap? It’s so pretty that one glance will immediately tell you that it’s not your ordinary supermarket soap. This is traditionally crafted in the Provence region of France and contains few impurities, which is good because impurities are what you are hoping to remove, not add to your skin. Other things you may like about this product are the fragrance, its creamy lather, and its paraben-free ingredient list.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 250g
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: 

Features & Benefits

Triple-Milled Bar

Longevity tends to be a problem with specially formulated soaps. It’s a great thing that this soap is triple-milled because that means it will last way longer than the typical exfoliating soap on the market today.

Traditional Production

We love that every bar of this variant is made by soap makers in Provence. These are not assembly line-produced soaps that come into contact with so many possible industrial contaminants.

Rich Lather

The creamy lather of this soap bar makes the exfoliating action a lot smoother and easier on the skin. Furthermore, it gives you a luxurious feeling. It’s as if your body is being cuddled while all that dead skin is being removed.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    A great novelty gift
  • check-circle
    Nice lather
  • check-circle
    Few impurities
  • times-circle
    Very fragrant and may irritate some

3. Dove Men+Care Body and Face Bar Deep Clean

Description

It looks like Dove fully understands the skin care needs not only of ours but also of men’s. This variant of their exfoliating soap bar contains the same basic formula as that of the variant for women but has a few add-ons. This comes with purifying micrograins, which will definitely serve men well because their skin need more exfoliating action than ours do. It also has a unique technology that produces easy-to-rinse lather.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 4 oz
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: moisturizing cream, micrograins
  • asterisk
    Scent: Mild and clean
  • asterisk
    Where to Apply: Hand, body

Features & Benefits

Lather Technology

It is important that the lather and bubbles of a soap are easily and quickly rinsed off because the longer they stay on the skin, the more they can dry your skin. Plus, we don’t think men are as willing as us to stay long in the shower!

Purifying Micrograins

We think your loved one will love the micrograins in this soap bar because unlike the microbeads or scrubs in other soaps, these are very mild on the skin. They work their way into the pores to remove all that dead skin without damaging the new skin.

Moisturizing Cream

There’s no reason men shouldn’t get to take advantage of Dove’s famous moisturizing cream formula. It’s in this product, and it nourishes your loved one’s skin the way it cares for yours!

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Gently exfoliates
  • check-circle
    Has moisturizing cream
  • check-circle
    Rinses off quickly
  • times-circle
    It is scented

4. Dr. Squatch Eucalyptus Greek Yogurt Natural Soap (Men)

Description

The key ingredients in this soap bar from Dr. Squatch are eucalyptus oil and Greek yogurt extract. Eucalyptus oil is known to open up the pores, letting all the impurities out as you wash. Meanwhile, Greek yogurt extract is good at fighting dirt and grime. There are also oatmeal bits in this soap, which provide added exfoliating action. Overall, this soap appears to be geared for maximum exfoliation, which is exactly what your loved one’s thick, dirty skin needs!

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 0.8 oz (approx.)
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: eucalyptus oil, Greek yogurt extract, oatmeal

Features & Benefits

Eucalyptus Oil

Aside from opening up the pores, eucalyptus has many other benefits for the skin. It has antiseptic properties and has a relaxing effect, which is why it is commonly used in aromatherapy.

Greek Yogurt Extract

Yogurt is rich in lactic acid, which dissolves dead skin and tightens up your pores. It is also known to have the same effect on the stubborn dirt and grime that cling to the surface of the skin.

Oatmeal Bits

We like oats for their mild exfoliating power. You can rub all you want without damaging the new skin underneath all those dead skin cells, unlike the case with other exfoliating soaps, which have coarse beads.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Very effective exfoliant
  • check-circle
    Lots of ingredients that promote exfoliation
  • times-circle
    Does not last at all

5. Noble Formula 2% Pyrithione Zinc (ZnP) Argan Oil Bar Soap

Description

This soap from Noble Formula also packages exfoliation and moisture in one bar. You have argan oil and olive oil, which are packed with hydrating properties and antioxidants that make them ideal anti-aging product ingredients. The active ingredient is pyrithione zinc, which does more than just exfoliate. You may like this product if you want a soap with antibacterial properties.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 3.25 oz
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: pyrithione zinc, olive oil, argan oil

Features & Benefits

Pyrithione Zinc

As we mentioned earlier, pyrithione zinc has many benefits for the skin. However, what we’re looking for is exfoliation specifically. You may become as impressed as we are about the fact that ZnP does more than just unblock pores. It slows down the production of skin cells, thereby indirectly reducing flaking.

Olive Oil

It is great that the manufacturer added olive oil in this soap for a more balanced effect. Olive oil is a very good moisturizer and significantly reduces flaking. It strengthens your skin’s natural barrier.

Argan Oil

Commonly used as a moisturizer, argan oil is rich in vitamin E and fatty acids, which your skin definitely love. It naturally hydrates and softens your skin. It is also not greasy so it should not irritate you.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Rich in moisturizers
  • check-circle
    Uses oatmeal and milled oats as main exfoliants
  • times-circle
    Doesn’t lather

6. The Yellow Bird Lavender Goat Milk Soap Bar

Description

If you are looking for a good all-around exfoliating soap, this pretty bar from The Yellow Bird looks like a good option. As is printed on the label, its main ingredients are goat milk, oatmeal, and lavender. Obviously, oatmeal is the exfoliant, which is great even for sensitive skin because it’s so gentle. Goat milk is high in vitamins, minerals, and naturally occurring glycerin, which are the very ingredients other companies try to produce in labs for beauty products. Finally, you have lavender, which has a soothing effect and antiseptic properties. It’s got a little bit of everything.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 4.5 oz
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: goat milk, oatmeal, lavender

Features & Benefits

Goat Milk

As we said, goat milk is rich in skin-friendly vitamins and minerals. It is also actually commonly found in moisturizers now. Having goat milk in this soap means your skin is moisturized while being exfoliated.

Oatmeal

Oatmeal is the ultimate natural exfoliant. Similar to the other items on this list, this exfoliating soap has tiny oatmeal bits that provide gentle exfoliation. Since oatmeal is relatively soft and is a natural substance, you should be okay with this even if you have sensitive skin.

Lavender

Lavender essential oil has numerous benefits. One of the main ones is its soothing effect. We think it’s smart that The Yellow Bird put this ingredient here because it’s possible to hurt your skin during exfoliation.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Made with certified organic ingredients
  • check-circle
    All-in-one skin care
  • check-circle
    No animal testing
  • times-circle
    Strong fragrance

7. Aspen Kay Naturals Oatmeal Soap Bar

Description

We like this product primarily because it is made of certified organic ingredients. A lot of companies nowadays just carelessly throw around the word “organic” across their products for as long as they can legally get away with it. It’s nice that a company does use certified organic substances for their product. This soap also uses oatmeal as its gentle exfoliant, and then adds moisturizing goat milk and organic honey for a complete skin care routine.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Weight: 4 oz
  • asterisk
    Key Ingredients: organic oats, organic honey, goat milk

Features & Benefits

Goat Milk

A lot of hydrating skin products today use goat milk because of its inherent moisturizing properties. It is rich in protein, vitamin A, and other vitamins and minerals that improve the look and health of the skin.

Oats

This soap uses organic oats as one of its key ingredients. Oatmeal is a gentle natural exfoliator that scrubs away at dead skin cells, grime, and dirt without damaging the skin.

Honey

Honey is great for the skin because it is rich in antioxidants that soothe, improve the complexion, and reducing the appearance of the signs of aging. Not a lot of skin care products have honey in them, and if you have not tried it, we think this is the right time to start!

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Uses certified organic ingredients
  • check-circle
    Gentle enough for any skin type
  • check-circle
    Lathers well
  • times-circle
    Fragrant

Alternative Choices

If you don’t think our recommendations will produce your desired results, you can instead try one of the alternatives we’ve listed here.

1. Yardley London Soap Bath Bar

The main ingredients in this soap are almond and oatmeal, which are polar opposites of each other. Oatmeal is an exfoliant, and almond is ultra-rich in vitamin E, which makes it a great moisturizer. It is not fragrant, but it does come with a subtle warm scent. We think you will like this product if you like to keep things simple. Also, the good thing about products that do not cram too many ingredients into one bar is that the properties of each ingredient gets highlighted more.

2. Jack Black Turbo Body Bar Scrubbing Soap

This is another nice gift to give to your guy friends. The Turbo Body ar is indeed a scrubbing soap. Like many of the other exfoliating soap bars in this guide, this one from Jack Black has moisturizing shea butter and murumuru. But that is about where the similarity ends. The Turbo Body Bar’s exfoliant is a natural lava rock. Talk about extreme scrubbing. Maybe friends who are into dirty or intense sports or jobs will enjoy this. It also has elements (blue lotus and gingko biloba) that stimulate the senses and help fight fatigue.

3. Baxter of California Men's Exfoliating Body Bar

This exfoliating soap bar for men uses pumice, jojoba meal, and crushed olive seed for combined exfoliation and moisture. According to the manufacturer, it is safe for any skin type. It is also nicely packaged and expensive, so we think it makes a nice token for a close friend who enjoys pampering himself every now and then.

4. Piona Exfoliating and Brightening Soap

Manufacturer Piona does not just promise exfoliation but brightening as well (although if you think about it, proper exfoliation does lead to brightening inevitably). It combines camomile oil, jojoba oil, vitamin E, and aloe vera extract. On paper, it looks like there’s enough moisturizing ingredients in there to balance out the exfoliation, but the product is still a little strong. We recommend that you avoid using it in your face the first few times. See what it does to your body first.

5. Falls River Soap Company Himalayan Pink Salt Bar Soap

This exfoliating soap bar is unique. Rarely do we hear of a soap with rose clay and Himalayan pink salt. These ingredients exfoliate your skin by drawing out the impurities and the toxins. That means it goes beyond just removing dirt and goes one step further by detoxifying your skin too. Other ingredients include charcoal, English rose, and red Brazilian Mandarin essential oil. This is a nice option if you want to try something new and unusual but still all-natural.

6. My Doctor Suggests Organic Exfoliating Silver Soap

We have been hearing about silver soap for a while now. This certain variant, which is manufactured by My Doctor Suggests, is made with 30 ppm (parts per million) of silver hydrosol solution. This is believed to promote skin healing, among others. The other ingredients are certified organic, and there is a “mild oatmeal spice scent.” Be careful when trying it out, especially if you are not used to products like this.

7. Aspen Kay Naturals Coffee and Oatmeal Exfoliating Soap

This soap from Aspen Kay Naturals has certified organic ground coffee and certified organic oats. There are also therapeutic-grade essential oils in it for added moisture. The other ingredients include shea butter, olive oil, sustainable palm oil, castor bean oil, and sunflower oil, all of which are certified organic. We have heard about coffee’s potential as a skin care product, but right now, we still do not see a lot of products with it as the main ingredient. Maybe you can try this if you feel like trying something new!

8. Greenwich Bay Trading Exfoliating Gardener Shea Butter Soap (set)

This sampler set is a good buy if you want to give something nice to someone or if you just want to try them yourself. The set has 4 shea butter soaps with different aromatic scents (fresh milk and jasmine, lemon verbena, cucumber and freesia, and lavender sunflower). They are just slightly different in terms of content. However, you need to stay away from this if you don’t like scented soaps. They are very fragrant and may trigger allergies.

9. Irish Spring Signature Exfoliating Bar Soap

We love the look of the Irish Spring Signature Exfoliating Bar Soap because nothing can possibly look manlier than it. Anyway, this is also for men, so do not expect to find the same gentle oatmeal here that you usually find in your own exfoliating soaps. This soap uses authentic milled oats to scrub all that thick dead skin off your beau’s body the way it should be done!

10. Fair & White Savon AHA-2 Exfoliating and Lightening Soap

This exfoliating soap bar from Fair & White is a “deep pore-cleansing soap” that promotes new skin cell growth by effectively removing the dead cells in the way. It also promises to brighten up the skin and give it a radiant glow. It also has antibacterial properties. You may like this product if you have problems with scars too. By lightening the skin around the scar (which is generally lighter than the skin around it), the scar becomes less noticeable.

11. Earth Therapeutics Loofah Exfoliating Soap (set)

This is another cute gift option for women. In a set, you get three assorted variants of the loofah exfoliating soap from Earth Therapeutics: oatmeal and honey, aloe vera and kiwi, and peaches and passion. The name of the product is not simply a catchy name. It is indeed a bar formulated with loofah fibers, and the bar itself is a vegetable-based treatment soap bar. The added “flavors” are for soothing and stimulating the senses and the skin.

12. Crystal Peel Microdermabrasion Exfoliating Soap Body Bar

We see this microdermabrasion exfoliating bar an “advanced” option because of two reasons. First, it promises way more than just exfoliation. The manufacturer says this soap stimulates the production of collagen, which is a key anti-aging agent, and helps minimize hyperpigmentation. How? With fine crystals from the Dead Sea, no less. To be specific, we’re talking fine corundum and magnesium oxide crystals. Those are effective but harsh, so don’t use this on your face.

13. Splendor Santa Barbara Exfoliating Soap

If you are a fan of handmade soaps, this would be a great product for your bathroom. Aside from exfoliation, this soap is infused with antibacterial, antifungal, and antiviral properties too. This is good if you want natural ingredients with a lot of extras. Its main content is called litsea cubeba, which is believed to be an antioxidant that helps prevent diseases.

14. Greenwich Bay Trading Company Almond Exfoliating Spa Soap

You may like this soap if you want to be very cautious about your exfoliating products. This bar has almond oil, shea butter, and creamy cocoa butter, which are all super hydrating. Unlike many of the bars on this list, though, this product does not use oats for exfoliating. It uses cocoa bean shells. It is also triple-milled, so you know it will last longer than most formulated soaps.

15. Irish Spring Signature Exfoliating Bar Soap (set)

This is a set of the exfoliating soap for men that we mentioned earlier. You get to save a lot by going for this option regardless of whether you’re giving the soaps out as gifts or stocking them at home for your hubby. They may like the special exfoliating effect of the authentic milled oats used in this soap.

Alternative Choices Comparison Table

Yardley London Soap Bath Bar

Jack Black Turbo Body Bar Scrubbing Soap

Baxter of California Men's Exfoliating Body Bar

Piona Exfoliating and Brightening Soap

Falls River Soap Company Himalayan Pink Salt Bar Soap

Weight

4.25 oz

2.9 oz (approx.)

7 oz

7 oz

4 oz

Key Ingredients

Oatmeal, almond

Natural lava rock

Pumice jojoba meal, olive seed

Camomile oil, jojoba oil, vitamin E

Himalayan pink salt, rose clay

Ratings

My Doctor Suggests Organic Exfoliating Silver Soap

Aspen Kay Naturals Coffee and Oatmeal Exfoliating Soap

Greenwich Bay Trading Exfoliating Gardener Shea Butter Soap (set)

Irish Spring Signature Exfoliating Bar Soap

Fair & White Savon AHA-2 Exfoliating and Lightening Soap

Weight

4 oz

4 oz

1.9 oz/pc

6 oz

7 oz

Key Ingredients

Silver hydrosol solution

Ground coffee, oats

Lemon verbena, shea butter

Milled oats

Allantoin

Ratings

Earth Therapeutics Loofah Exfoliating Soap (set)

Crystal Peel Microdermabrasion Exfoliating Soap Body Bar

Splendor Santa Barbara Exfoliating Soap

Greenwich Bay Trading Company Almond Exfoliating Spa Soap

Irish Spring Signature Exfoliating Bar Soap (set)

Weight

4.2 oz

8 oz

3.5 oz

6.35 oz

6 oz

Key Ingredients

Oatmeal, honey; aloe vera, kiwi; peaches, passion

Corundum and magnesium oxide crystals (Dead Sea)

Litsea, poppy seeds

Almond oil, shea butter

Milled oats

Ratings

Conclusion

Instead of inadvertently damaging your skin by exfoliating with harsh products, why not go for a mild option and see how it goes? We recommend Dove Men+Care Body and Face Bar Deep Clean because it gets rid of impurities and dead skin cells effectively while remaining incredibly mild on the skin.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments