Best Handcrafted Soap Bars (Top 5 Choices + 13 Alternatives)

Introduction

Every time we hear the term ” soap bars”, we always picture those paper-wrapped, plain soaps that we find, either in hotel bathrooms, or in the shelves of grocery stores. They are the ones that almost always end up melting into the shower after a single use.

If that is the case, it seems that our imagination of soap bars are defined by the way the media is portraying them. However, there is much more about soap bars that make them interesting. Have you tried using handcrafted soap bars before? These soap bars are not considered as the traditional ones, as they are usually formulated using special ingredients, and as the name suggests – handcrafted.

Much effort has been put into the process of creating these handcrafted soaps, thus adding to their quality. There are a lot of options available right now in the market. We have created a list of the best handcrafted soap bars for you to make decisions easier. We have also included some tips on how to choose the best one.

​Top 3 Choices

1. Vi- Tae Organic Antibacterial Soap

One standout feature that makes this soap one of the most popular out there is that it comes equipped with anti-bacterial properties. At the same time, it uses only all-natural, and plant based ingredients which means that it is also well recommended, even for vegans.

If you are searching for a handcrafted soap that can give you the anti-bacterial qualities that you are looking for, and finally address some of the most worst skin conditions, this soap bar is a well-recommended option that you can take into consideration. 

2. Noble Formula 2% Pyrithione Zinc (ZnP) Argan Oil Bar Soap

What makes this soap a standout option included in this list is the fact that it is equipped with 2% Pyrithione Zinc. This form of zinc is known not just for its anti-bacterial properties, but anti-fungal at the same time. As such, this soap is designed primarily for individuals who are dealing with some of the most annoying skin conditions.

If you are suffering from skin condition such as psoriasis, eczema as well as extreme dullness and dryness, this soap bar is a great option to consider. Aside from zinc, it is also packed with essential oils which can give your skin the hydration and moisturizing effect that it needs. 

3. Peppermint & Tea Tree Soap Bar. All Natural Antifungal Soap for Acne, Athlete's Foot, Ringworm, Jock Itch. Organic Body & Face Wash for Men and Women

This handcrafted soap bar combines together the power of peppermint and tea tree in its concoction. It is designed for use on all types of skin, and can be used as a face and body soap, as well as a hand soap. It uses organic ingredients which are selected for their anti-fungal properties, thus making it an ideal option for those who are suffering from dry and itchy skin, as well as rashes.

As a bonus, its combination of peppermint and tea tree makes this soap relaxing to the senses. It is also perfect for use by both men and women who loves to indulge in this sensational soap bar. 

Top 3 Choices - Comparison Table

Vi-Tae Organic Anti-Bacterial Soap

Noble Formula 2% Pyrithione Zinc (ZnP) Argan Oil Bar Soap

Peppermint & Tea Tree Soap Bar

Ingredients

Essential Oils

2% ZnP; Argan Oil

Peppermint; Tea Tree

Product Weight

4 oz.

3.25 oz.

4 oz.

Special Features

Anti-bacterial; Organic

Anti-fungal; Anti-bacterial

Anti-fungal

Who Is It For?

Handcrafted soap bars are generally for those who would like to skip out of the ordinary, commercial soaps that have aligned the shelves of supermarkets. These commercialized soap bars are usually field with additives which may be harmful to the skin. Since they are synthetic, they usually end up more affordable, but may leave some unlikely impact on your skin.

If you would like to try out of the ordinary, and would like to experience a healthier option when it comes to the type of soap that you use at home, then finding the best handcrafted soap bars is also for you. Now is the time for you to switch path and try new things, especially if it brings more benefits to you than what you have been accustomed to.

Buyer's Guide

Advantages of Using the Best Handcrafted Soap Bars

Here are some of the advantages that you can expect out of handcrafted soap bars:

All-natural Ingredients
This is, by far, one of the best reasons why you should use handcrafted soaps. The ingredients used in the formulation of these soaps are selected vegetable oils and butters which are rich with vitamins, nutrients and antioxidants which are essential to having and maintaining a healthy skin.

Safe and Harmless
If you opt for a handcrafted soap, you can be sure that the process involved in the manufacturing is save. No humans and animals were also harmed, impoverished or endangered during the process. Therefore, if you consider yourself a protector of the environment, this is the best option to go.

Variety
If you are interested in variety, handcrafted soap bars will never disappoint you. Regardless of your skin type, needs and personal preferences, there is a soap that is meant for you. There are different recipes, flavors and aromas for you to choose from, which makes it more exciting to try them all out!

What to Look for When Purchasing Handcrafted Soap Bars

As mentioned, there are several options which may be presented in front of you. In order to make the right choice, here are some factors that you need to consider as you purchase handcrafted soap bars:

Selected Ingredients Used
A dependable and experienced soap maker will be able to tell you all the ingredients used in the creation of the soap. Most importantly, they can also specify the benefits that you can expect out of those ingredients.

Type of Process
There are different processes that the soapmaker may have used in creating the soap. They may include hot or cold process, as well as melt and pour. Each of these processes come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages, which means that you can choose the one that you think is best for you.

Certification
Dedicated soap makers always have the opportunity to get their name certified through different organizations. Hundreds of soapmakers receive certification each year by investing in money and time into testing and education in order to make sure that they produce a skin-safe and high quality product. 

Review of Top 5 Products

1. Vi- Tae Organic Antibacterial Soap

Description

If you are trying to avoid harsh chemicals commonly found in over-the-shelves soaps, this anti-bacterial soap from Vi-Tae is a good option to take into consideration. This product only uses all-natural ingredients which are also recommended even for vegans.

Ingredients

  • asterisk
    Patchouli
  • asterisk
    Lemongrass
  • asterisk
    Lime
  • asterisk
    Coconut Oil
  • asterisk
    Safflower Oil
  • asterisk
    Sunflower

Features & Benefits

Anti-bacterial Properties
This is achieved by the use of ingredients that are known for their anti-bacterial properties. These ingredients include lemongrass, lime and patchouli which are tough on germs, but reliably gentle for the skin.

Deep Hydration
Even though other anti-bacterial soaps leave the skin dry and rough, this product contains oils that ensure deep hydration on your skin. As such, you can pamper your skin safely while keeping it clean.

Organic
This soap is handmade and only contains plant-based ingredients. It is also 100% vegan, which means that it was not tested on animals.

Luxurious Feel
This soap can be used after a very long day at work, and after being exposed to harmful chemicals in the environment, and you can expect a luxurious feel as you take your bath, thus melting your stress away.

Risk Free
If you are not satisfied with the product, rest assured you can return it with its money back guarantee promise.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Anti-bacterial
  • check-circle
    Deep hydration
  • check-circle
    Organic ingredients used
  • check-circle
    Risk free guarantee
  • check-circle
    Made in the USA
  • times-circle
    The bar dissolves fast

Conclusion

If you are looking for a handcrafted soap that is vegan and organic at the same time, this is the best choice you can get. This soap only uses organic ingredients in order to fight harmful bacteria in the skin surface naturally. At the same time, it also nourishes and hydrates the skin for that gorgeous and smooth look.

2. Mens Soap - Cedar Citrus Scented Natural Bar Soap for Men - Skin and Body Nourishing - Handmade in USA

Description

The main tagline of the manufacturer is that you can treat your skin like a king by using this handcrafted soap bar. It offers an energizing and refreshing blend of orange and rustic cedar oil, thus giving you that all-natural goodness that you cannot usually find in commercial soaps.

Soaps Variety

  • asterisk
    Cedar Citrus
  • asterisk
    Pine Tar
  • asterisk
    Spearmint Basil Scrub
  • asterisk
    Nautical Sage

Features & Benefits

Cold-pressed
Since this soap is cold-pressed, it means that the glycerin is retained in the soap bar. When combined with olive and coconut oils, it results to ultimate nourishment of your skin with its much needed nutrients.

Preservative and Chemical Free
As a bar soap that passed through a cold process, there is no need to add harsh preservatives or chemicals. As a result, you can experience the best soap that will leave your skin smooth and safe.

Great Scent for Men
The scents of these soap bars are highly geared towards men. Since the manufacturer stayed away from flowery scents, it is perfect for those who likes masculine smells.

Promo Available
The manufacturer also offers a limited time promo. When you purchase 4 bar of soap, you get the 5th soap bar for free. This means more savings on your part.

Satisfaction guaranteed

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Anti-bacterial
  • check-circle
    Deep hydration
  • check-circle
    Organic ingredients used
  • check-circle
    Risk free guarantee
  • check-circle
    Made in the USA
  • times-circle
    The bar dissolves fast

Conclusion

By supporting handcrafted products, such as these organic soaps from Dr. Squatch, you are not just making sure that you are using the healthiest options for your skin, but you are also supporting small businesses. More importantly, you are embracing a more natural lifestyle that will allow you to safeguard your health, while indulging at the same time.

3. Noble Formula 2% Pyrithione Zinc (ZnP) Argan Oil Bar Soap

Description

This soap is formulated to have anti-bacterial and anti-fungal properties. As such, this soap is highly recommended for those who are suffering from certain skin conditions, including eczema, psoriasis, as well as those who have sensitive and dry skin.

Product Information

  • asterisk
    Olive oil
  • asterisk
    Argan oil
  • asterisk
    Oatmeal
  • asterisk
    2% Pyrithione Zinc

Features & Benefits

2% Pyrithione Zinc Added
The addition of 2% Pyrithione Zinc is the reason why this soap bar is equipped with anti-bacterial and anti-fungal properties. Pyrithione Zinc, or ZnP is a form of zinc that is known for having these skin treating properties.

Nourishing and Moisturizing

Aside from ZnP, this soap also contains other oils as ingredients, including olive oil which gives nourishment, as well as argan oil, which moisturizes the skin. The addition of oatmeal also helps in exfoliating the skin gently.

Good for any Skin Type
This cleansing bar is excellent for use on any skin type. However, it is primarily designed for those who are suffering from skin conditions.

Made in the USA
Knowing that the product is made in the USA offers a guarantee that it went through high standard processing. At the same time, you are also supporting small businesses in the country.

Targets Sensitive Skin
Sensitive skin is usually prone to conditions such as eczema, psoriasis, and dryness. This soap targets this skin type, thus making a good solution for those who are dealing with these conditions.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Also improves skin texture
  • check-circle
    Cures different skin condition
  • check-circle
    Works on different skin types
  • check-circle
    Made in the USA
  • check-circle
    Natural oils used
  • times-circle
    Does not foam well

Conclusion

If you are dealing with skin conditions such as eczema, psoriasis and extreme dryness, this bar soap from Noble Formula is the best option that you can take into consideration. The addition and mix of ingredients make it effective, not just in treating skin conditions, but also making sure that skin is left well-nourished and moisturized.

4. SoapWorks Tea Tree Soap Bar

Description

We all know the power of tea tree oil. Have you ever imagined it being incorporated with several other ingredients, thus producing a highly dependable, handcrafted soap bar? This tea tree soap bar from Soap Works achieves just that.

Ingredients

  • asterisk
    Glycerin
  • asterisk
    Sodium Palm Kernelate
  • asterisk
    Sodium Palmate
  • asterisk
    Palm Kernel Acid
  • asterisk
    Sodium Chloride
  • asterisk
    Australian Tea Tree Oil

Features & Benefits

All-vegetable Soap
The main ingredient used in this handcrafted soap bar is Melaleuka Alternifolia leaf oil, otherwise known as Australian tea tree oil. All the other ingredients used in the formulation of this soap are also all-natural, and plant-based.

Cleaning and Anti-bacterial Properties
This soap is great for both shampooing and shaving. It serves as a mild astringent, with other cleaning properties such as being anti-septic, non-irritating, as well as anti-fungal.

Smells Good
While other commercialized soaps claiming to use tea tree oil in their formulation may have an overly strong smell, this soap bar offers a nice and relaxing smell. Still, you can tell that there is a lot of tea tree oil added to it.

Vegan
If you are a supporter against cruelty to animals, this product is the best option to take into consider. After all, this is a vegan product, which means that it was not tested on animals, and it also does not use animal-based ingredients.

Nice and Soapy
One common problem among other handcrafted soap bars is that they have the tendency to become less soapy. This soap, however, creates a good lather, thus allowing you to enjoy your shower very much.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Nice tea tree oil scent
  • check-circle
    Solid soap
  • check-circle
    All-natural ingredients
  • check-circle
    Vegan
  • check-circle
    Phosphate-free
  • times-circle
    Does not moisturize well

Conclusion

This all-vegetable soap is handcrafted from Canada, which also explains the quality of the product. It is equipped with tea tree oil, which is known for its non-irritating, anti-fungal and anti-septic properties. One thing noticeable about this soap is that it is solid, and does not melt easily.

5. Peppermint & Tea Tree Soap Bar. All Natural Antifungal Soap for Acne, Athlete's Foot, Ringworm, Jock Itch. Organic Body & Face Wash for Men and Women

Description

If you are a fan of peppermint and tea tree oils, this is the best option that you can have. Aside from the fact that it smells great, it is also equipped with anti-fungal properties, making it effective for skin conditions including athlete’s foot, acne, ringworm, and several others.

Ingredients

  • asterisk
    Sustainable Organic Palm Oil
  • asterisk
    Organic Sunflower Oil
  • asterisk
    Organic Olive Oil
  • asterisk
    Organic Coconut Oil
  • asterisk
    Tea Tree Essential Oil
  • asterisk
    Peppermint Essential Oil
  • asterisk
    Peppermint Leaves
  • asterisk
    Cajeput Essential Oil

Features & Benefits

Anti-fungal Properties
Because of the anti-fungal properties of this soap bar, it is highly capable of taking itches away. With the use of several organic ingredients in its formulation, most of which are known for giving anti-fungal relief for various types of itchy and dry skin conditions and rashes, this soap is recommended for those who are having these problems.

No Irritations
This soap is only made out of all-natural, gentle and vegan ingredients. As such, they are guaranteed to keep your skin healthy all the time. It is free of chemicals, and does not have harmful substances such as alcohol, parabens, artificial dyes as well as other synthetic fragrances.

Satisfaction Guarantee
The manufacturer of this product offers a money back. This means that if you are not satisfied with the quality of the soap that you received, you can simply return the soap, and you will get a full refund.

Handcrafted in the USA
This fact means that you can have a wonderful opportunity of supporting the smaller business of the country. As they are also handcrafted, they are made using traditional methods in small batches.

Cold Pressed
The process of cold pressing is the best way to preserve the effectiveness and integrity of the high quality ingredients used in the formulation of the product.

Pros

Cons

  • check-circle
    Made in the USA
  • check-circle
    Anti-fungal
  • check-circle
    Chemical free
  • check-circle
    Ideal even for sensitive skin
  • check-circle
    Organic and Vegan
  • times-circle
    More expensive than traditional soaps

Conclusion

Among the positive points about this soap bar is that it offers an invigorating and uplifting scent profile that will certainly leave you feeling fresh all the time. With the use of tea tree essential oil, it is endowed with anti-fungal properties which help in dealing with several skin conditions.

Alternative Choices

1.Colloidal Silver Soap 

This colloidal silver soap is unscented, which means that it is ideal for you if you do not want to use a handcrafted soap that is scented with essential oils. No color is also added to this soap, making it all-natural, but very effective. Because of the use of natural ingredients in the formulation of this soap, you may have to expect some variations in color and spots, but this is normal and does not affect the quality of the soap.

2.Amish Farms Quality Handmade Soap Variety Bag 5 soaps

This pack is consist of 5 soap bars, at 4 oz. each. They come in different colors, and are naturally cut uneven, so no need for you to be shocked the moment you open the pack. It is naturally handmade, without sodium, laurel sulfate or parabens. It comes with a wildflower scent, which is light to the nose. If you want variety in your soaps, this is the best option for you.

3.SOAP WORKS Coal Tar Bar Soap

The use of coal tar on this soap makes it very unique and interesting. Despite its color, it does not diminish the quality of cleaning that it can do on your skin. This product is gluten-free which means that it is safe if you are a vegan. It was also processed and manufactured without harming other people and animals, as this product was not tested on animals. It also does not contain Lauretha sulphate in its formulation.

4.Oatmeal Soap Bar

This oatmeal, milk and honey bar is made out of certified natural and organic olive oil, shea butter, as well as sustainable palm oil, among others. It is a mild exfoliating bar which produces a wonderful lather. Using this soap bar is soothing to the skin, especially for those that are prone to irritation. This is formulated for use on all types of skin, and can be used as a face and body soap.

5.Handmade Goat Milk Soap Oatmeal 'n Honey Soap

If you are looking goat milk handcrafted soap, this is a good option to consider. It does not use any chemical fragrance, dyes, or fillers. This product is primarily designed for those with sensitive skin, which means that every ingredient used in the formulation is chosen carefully and used purposely. No water is used in the recipe, only 100% raw goat milk, giving you a luxurious milk bath feel, and leaving your skin refreshed and rejuvenated.

6.Bamboo Charcoal Soap Bars With Dead Sea Mud 

This soap is ideal for you if you are dealing with certain skin conditions such as eczema, psoriasis, acne, as well as dry sensitive skin. A lot of customers swear to the effectiveness of this product. It is made out of all-natural ingredients, including bamboo activated charcoal, Dead Sea mint, olive oil, and several other essential oils. Your purchase also includes a bonus soap sock that can be used for exfoliating your skin.

7.Lavender Goats Milk Soap Bar. 100% Natural and Organic Soap

This soap is made using traditional, old-fashioned methods in soap manufacturing. This means that the recipe used in the formulation of this product has been handed down from one generation to another, making it one of the best natural options out there. It is a luxurious milk soap made out of goat’s milk, scented naturally with some therapeutic grade lavender essential oil, as well as a hint of the special ylang-ylang oil. It is also designed for all types of skin, and is gentle enough even for sensitive skin. It can be used as a face or body soap, as well as a shaving soap. If you are not satisfied with this product, the manufacturer offers a risk free guarantee for your purchase.

8.Santa Monica Soap Co. Handmade Soap - Orange Crush

This Orange Crush soap is one of the bestselling soaps under this brand. While other soaps are filled with fruity scents, this soap just provides enough of that sun-ripened orange scent which is not irritating to the nose. It is neither girl nor juvenile, but it is fit for everybody, giving that instant mood lift. As a bonus, this soap comes in a beautiful marbleized look which is further enhanced by the use of freshly sliced orange appearance within the layers of the soap bars.

9.[USA] Organic Bamboo Charcoal Soap Bar [SAPO] 

This product is 100% all-natural, which means that you can have a peace of mind knowing that the ingredients used in the manufacturing of this product are certified organic and handmade. It is also moisturizing and gentle, leaving your skin feeling fresh, supple, soft and completely moisturized. This soap is ideal for individuals who have sensitive skin. It also helps those with skin conditions such as breakouts, acne, eczema, psoriasis, as well as other proven effective ingredients.

10.Tea Tree Soap (Tea Tree Oil Bath Bar Soap) - Handmade Herbal Soap (Aromatherapy) with 100% Pure Essential Oils

The use of tea tree oil in the formulation of this soap makes it an excellent anti-bacterial and anti-fungal solution to different types of skin conditions. Tea tree oil is unfailingly useful when it comes to cleansing and moisturizing. Aside from that, this soap can also be depended on when it comes to toning, because tea tree oil also acts as a natural toner which removes fine wrinkles and blemishes gently. This is recommended for use on all skin types.

11.Zum Bar Soap - Frankincense & Myrrh

The combination of goat’s milk, frankincense and myrrh makes this handcrafted soap a very dependable option if you want an all-natural soap that can give you that luxurious feel after a good bath. Of course, you can also anticipate the interesting smell that goes with it, but it does not hurt your nose in any way. It also serves as a good exfoliant to your skin, which removes dead skin cells, toning away fine lines and wrinkles.

12.I & SOAP, 5pcs Mini Sampler Set (01) - Guest Soap - Travel Soap 

This set is consist of 5 different soap bars. Every bar is wrapped individually, and not bunched together, thus you can be assured that the scents do not get mixed up. These bars were formulated to serve as anti-aging, exfoliating, moisturizing, and purifying bars. They are also meant for use on any skin type, whether sensitive or normal. Since the bars are especially handcrafted, you may have to expect that there can be minor variations in both weight and size.

13.Herbivore Botanicals - All Natural Bamboo Charcoal Face/Body Cleansing Soap Bar

This cleansing soap is power-packed and highly beneficial for individuals who have oily, acne prone and combination skin types. It is filled with activated bamboo charcoal and combined with tea tree and bergamot essential oils, making this soap bar a must-have when it comes to fighting bacteria, as well as in drawing out skin impurities. It is also purely natural and effective, which makes it highly recommended for vegans. 

Alternative Choices Comparison Table

Colloidal Silver Soap

Amish Farms Quality Handmade Soap

SOAP WORKS Coal Tar Bar Soap

Oatmeal Soap Bar

Handmade Goat Milk Soap Oatmeal 'n Honey Soap

Key Ingredients

Colloidal Silver

Essential Oils

Coal Tar

Oatmeal; Goat Milk

Oatmeal; Goat Milk

Product Weight

4.5 oz.

4 oz.

6 count

4 oz.

4.5 oz.

Special Features

Unscented

Wildflower Scent

Gluten Free

Gentle Exfoliation

Sold in 2s

Bamboo Charcoal Soap Bars With Dead Sea Mud

Lavender Goats Milk Soap Bar. 100% Natural and Organic Soap

Santa Monica Soap Co. Handmade Soap - Orange Crush

[USA] Organic Bamboo Charcoal Soap Bar [SAPO]

Tea Tree Soap (Tea Tree Oil Bath Bar Soap)

Key Ingredients

Bamboo Charcoal

Lavender; Goat Milk

Vegetable Based

Organic Bamboo Charcoal

Tea Tree Oil

Product Weight

4 oz.

4 oz.

4 oz.

4 oz.

2.65 oz.

Special Features

Dead Sea Mud

Traditional Preparation

Cold Processed

Exfoliates and Detoxifies

Anti-bacterial

Zum Bar Soap - Frankincense & Myrrh

I & SOAP, 5pcs Mini Sampler Set (01) - Guest Soap - Travel Soap

Herbivore Botanicals - All Natural Bamboo Charcoal Face/Body Cleansing Soap Bar

Key Ingredients

Frankincense & Myrrh

All-Natural & Organic

Natural Bamboo Charcoal

Product Weight

3 oz.

5.6 oz.

4 oz.

Special Features

All-Natural Soap

5 Sample Bars

Cleansing Soap Bar

Conclusion

With the options on handcrafted soap bars currently available on the market today, choosing the best one can really be difficult. However, with the guide we have presented above, you have an idea on how to choose the soap bar that is right for you. After all, what is right for another person may not be good for you. Therefore, it is recommended to list down the features that you would like to see, the specific ingredients that you would like included in the soap bar that you will be ordering, and start picking from there.

Our recommended product is the Vi-Tae Anti-bacterial soap. It is a well-preferred soap, as seen in the number of reviews it has received. This speaks a lot about the quality of this product. While this can work well with those who have sensitive skin, and dealing with skin conditions, it can also be used even for those with normal skin who just wants to have a healthier option on soap bars.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments